In this vid, “mathemusician” Vi Hart and Sal Khan (of the amazing Khanacademy) discuss the difference between linear and logarithmic scales and human perception. I like their joking idea of a liner scaled piano where the keys would get fatter and fatter as you moved up the scale.
For those who are sticklers enough to be annoyed by the fact that Vi just makes up frequency numbers for “C” (’cause she can’t remember the freq off the top of her head), on the blog Drew’s Day, Andrew Morrison provides some details Vi and Sal did not concern themselves with (the point of their video being more about conveying the idea of linear vs. logarithmic conceptually) and expands on several ideas.



You CAN see the logarithmic scale when looking inside a piano. The lengths of the strings correspond to the to the vibrating frequencies. The lowest notes have the longest strings and the upper notes have the shorter strings. So, the lowest C string IS (roughly) 4 times as long as its counterpart, 4 octaves higher.
Your idea of widening piano keys is interesting and funny, but the strings do show that piano makers think logarithmicaly - the keys are just a means to the sound, not the sound itself.
Wow, Vi Hart and Sal Khan, what a mind blowing combination.
This discussion reminds me of the “Numbers” episode of Radiolab. http://www.radiolab.org/2009/nov/30/ and http://www.radiolab.org/2009/nov/30/innate-numbers/ discusses how we naturally have a logarithmic concept of numbers.
Wow, Vi Hart and Sal Khan, what a mind blowing combination.
This discussion reminds me of the “Numbers” episode of Radiolab. http://www.radiolab.org/2009/nov/30/ and http://www.radiolab.org/2009/nov/30/innate-numbers/ discusses how we naturally have a logarithmic concept of numbers.
Wow, Vi Hart and Sal Khan, what a mind blowing combination.
This discussion reminds me of the “Numbers” episode of Radiolab. http://www.radiolab.org/2009/nov/30/ and http://www.radiolab.org/2009/nov/30/innate-numbers/ discusses how we naturally have a logarithmic concept of numbers.
woooooooowww
woooooooowww
// What's Trending
Raspberry Pi Design Contest
Maker Faire: Day Two
Seventeen Sneaky Secret Hides
10 Things to Connect to Your Raspberry Pi
Maker Faire: Day One
47 Raspberry Pi Projects to Inspire Your Next Build
DIY Hacks & How To’s: Swiss Army Key Ring
// What's Shared
A better way to slice a pumpkin
DIY Nerf Darts
In the Maker Shed: Minty Boost USB Charger
100 Dollar Store Organization Ideas for Craft Rooms and Beyond
Mad’s Mouse House
Lace Princess Crowns
I Have a (Puzzling) Dream
Play the Rings of a Tree Trunk Like a Record
// Most Commented
DIY Hacks & How To’s: Get Emergency Power from a Phone Line
Resin Casting: Going from CAD to Engineering-Grade Plastic Parts
Ten Tips for Screws and Screwdrivers
Ten Tips for Better Measurement
Makers on TV: Big Brain Theory
Arduino Announces New Wireless Linux Board
Build a “Boomcase” and Upcycle that Old Suitcase
Tool Review: BioLite CampStove
Trending Topics
Get our Newsletters
About Maker Media
Subscribe
to MAKE!
Get the print and digital versions when you subscribe