The goal was to make a light box for my students to use that didn't cost me an arm and a leg. Went to the second-hand store and found a florescent light... ($4.99 with 50% off) then noticed a suitcase/briefcase ($3.99 with 50% off). I got them both and started thinking of ways to put them together.
A cheap fluorescent lamp is going to have a poor spectrum and poor colour cast. It's easy to see in the picture the light is not well diffused. For any real photographic work, using this would be worse than using nothing and holding your material up to a bright window.
Tools are usually the worst possible place to cut corners because anybody is is only as good as their tools, and this is a great example.
I thought this was a great reuse project, but the primary thing I would use a light box for is to trace designs for embroidery or other line art, so no true color or perfect diffusion is necessary. It's a little mean to rag on this guy, a teacher, who's just trying to help his students succeed. This would be perfect for making simple stop-motion animations; I don't think it was ever intended to be for "real photographic work."
Posted by: Marc de Vinck on May 15, 2009 at 10:33 AM
Yep! It was made specifically "old school animation" so it's perfect!
In fact, my lightbox is all scratched up because I keep it on it's side in a closet, (not a great idea) this one has a lid, keeping the surface nice and smooth which is really important when inking.
Posted by: Gareth Branwyn on May 15, 2009 at 10:38 AM
Yeah, the drafting-angle light box that I've been using for the past 20 year, that I bought when I had a graphic design business, has hot spots and poorly-diffused light, and it works perfectly fine for what it was designed for -- which is tracing, cutting masks, etc.
The one above also has an undeniable Repo Man appeal.
Posted by: Gareth Branwyn on May 15, 2009 at 10:49 AM
Yeah. The one I have was sold as a "Light Table," even tho it doesn't actually have legs and goes on top of a table, so it really is a light box, but yeah, table vs. box might be the way these two tools are officially differentiated.
Posted by: Becky Stern on May 15, 2009 at 10:58 AM
I went to art school and always saw a bunch of "pora-trace" brand things we called light boxes. Here's a link that confirms some brands refer to a tracing box as a "light box" AND "light table": http://www.artsupply.com/alvin/lighttables.htm
I'm glad we're talking about two different pieces of equipment, that way we can all be happy.
Void your warranty, violate a user agreement, fry a circuit, blow a fuse, poke an eye out. Make: The risk-takers, the doers, the makers of things... Welcome to Make: Online!
More contributors: Mark Frauenfelder (Editor-in-Chief, MAKE magazine), Kipp Bradford (Technical Consultant/Writer), Chris Connors (Education), Diana Eng (Guest Author), Peter Horvath (Intern), Brian Jepson (O'Reilly Media), Robert Bruce Thompson (Science Room)
Behind the Scenes at MAKE and CRAFT
In January, many of the remote MAKE/CRAFT team members (myself included) convened at the Maker Media headquarters at O'Reilly Media in Sebastopol, California. Take a look behind the scenes of your favorite DIY publications as Goli Mohammadi gives us...
More...
Sign up for the Make: Newsletter
Our Make: Newsletter covers news from maker Media, has original columns, Shed deals, and more! You can also read the archives of past issues.
Why bother?
A cheap fluorescent lamp is going to have a poor spectrum and poor colour cast. It's easy to see in the picture the light is not well diffused. For any real photographic work, using this would be worse than using nothing and holding your material up to a bright window.
Tools are usually the worst possible place to cut corners because anybody is is only as good as their tools, and this is a great example.
Reply to this comment
I thought this was a great reuse project, but the primary thing I would use a light box for is to trace designs for embroidery or other line art, so no true color or perfect diffusion is necessary. It's a little mean to rag on this guy, a teacher, who's just trying to help his students succeed. This would be perfect for making simple stop-motion animations; I don't think it was ever intended to be for "real photographic work."
Reply to this comment
Yep! It was made specifically "old school animation" so it's perfect!
In fact, my lightbox is all scratched up because I keep it on it's side in a closet, (not a great idea) this one has a lid, keeping the surface nice and smooth which is really important when inking.
Reply to this comment
Yeah, the drafting-angle light box that I've been using for the past 20 year, that I bought when I had a graphic design business, has hot spots and poorly-diffused light, and it works perfectly fine for what it was designed for -- which is tracing, cutting masks, etc.
The one above also has an undeniable Repo Man appeal.
Reply to this comment
I think Becky's right on this one. From the instructable:
"Now I am ready to do some old school animation! I will still use the computer to scan, color and compile... but that will come another time."
I think the author meant to call this a "Light Table in a Box", rather than a "Light Box", which has a specific meaning in the photography world.
Reply to this comment
Why bother indeed. I tried using this to heat my bathwater and received a nasty shock. It's better to stick with store bought products.
Reply to this comment
Hey, just because you can't get it to work the way you want, don't insult makers ;).
Reply to this comment
Yeah. The one I have was sold as a "Light Table," even tho it doesn't actually have legs and goes on top of a table, so it really is a light box, but yeah, table vs. box might be the way these two tools are officially differentiated.
Reply to this comment
I went to art school and always saw a bunch of "pora-trace" brand things we called light boxes. Here's a link that confirms some brands refer to a tracing box as a "light box" AND "light table":
http://www.artsupply.com/alvin/lighttables.htm
I'm glad we're talking about two different pieces of equipment, that way we can all be happy.
Reply to this comment
I'm also glad it's two different pieces of equipment and I appologize to the designer for the tone of my earlier post.
Reply to this comment
Reuse!
Recover!
Recycle!
RETHINK!
This is a WONDERFUL project, period.
Reply to this comment